Skip to main content

Accounting

How to Value Closing Stock at Lower of Cost and NRV Under AS 2

Value closing stock under AS 2 step by step: build cost with normal-capacity overheads, keep out excluded costs and recoverable GST, choose FIFO or weighted average, and test each item against net realisable value with a worked example.

Share

How to Value Closing Stock at Lower of Cost and NRV Under AS 2

Under AS 2, closing stock goes into the balance sheet at the lower of cost and net realisable value, tested item by item. Most valuation errors happen before that comparison is even made: the cost figure itself is wrong because idle-capacity overheads, abnormal wastage, storage or recoverable GST were loaded into it. So valuing inventory under AS 2 is really two jobs. First build a clean cost per unit, then test each item against what it will actually fetch.

The rules sit in AS 2 (revised 2016), Valuation of Inventories. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs revised it for companies with effect from accounting periods beginning on or after 30 March 2016. ICAI made the revised text mandatory for other entities from accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2017. Paragraph numbers below follow that text, and the position is as checked on 20 November 2026.

Which entities and which stock AS 2 covers

ICAI's applicability appendix to the Compendium of Accounting Standards lists AS 2 among the standards that apply in full to companies not following Ind AS. For non-company entities it is marked applicable to Level II, III and IV entities with no relaxation, so a small partnership firm or proprietor whose accounts must follow ICAI standards values stock exactly as a company does. Companies on Ind AS follow Ind AS 2 instead, which is outside this piece.

The standard is not limited to finished goods. Paragraph 4 brings in goods bought for resale, work in progress, raw materials, stores, consumables and loose tools. Paragraphs 1 and 2 keep four things out:

  • work in progress under construction contracts, which AS 7 governs;
  • work in progress of service providers;
  • shares, debentures and other financial instruments held as stock-in-trade;
  • livestock, agricultural and forest produce, and mineral oils, ores and gases, where producers measure them at net realisable value under well-established industry practice.

Paragraph 4 also says spare parts, servicing equipment and standby equipment are not inventory when they meet the definition of property, plant and equipment under AS 10. A costly standby motor kept for a single machine belongs in fixed assets, not in stores.

The Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2021 carry the company version. The most recent amendment to those Rules, G.S.R. 169(E) dated 10 March 2026 (see the Companies (Accounting Standards) Amendment Rules, 2026), changed AS 22 for Pillar Two income taxes and left the AS 2 text as it was.

Building the cost figure: what goes in

Paragraph 6 defines cost as all costs of purchase, costs of conversion and other costs incurred in bringing the inventories to their present location and condition. Each of the three parts has its own trap.

Purchase cost and the GST question

Paragraph 7 includes the purchase price, import duties and other taxes that the enterprise cannot later recover from the tax authorities, inward freight, handling and other directly attributable costs. Trade discounts, rebates and duty drawbacks are deducted. The practical consequence for Indian businesses is GST. Where input tax credit is available, the GST is a recoverable tax and stays out of inventory cost. Where credit is blocked or the buyer is not registered, the GST is a real cost and goes into the stock value.

Conversion cost and normal capacity

Paragraph 8 adds direct labour plus a systematic allocation of fixed and variable production overheads. Fixed overheads (factory rent, depreciation of plant, factory management salaries) stay broadly the same whatever the output. Variable overheads such as indirect materials and power move with production.

Paragraph 9 is where most manufacturing valuations go wrong. Fixed overheads are absorbed on the basis of normal capacity, meaning the production expected on average over several periods under normal circumstances. If output falls because of a strike, a slow season or a breakdown, the fixed overhead per unit is not increased; the part that is not absorbed is charged to profit and loss in that year. In a year of abnormally high production the rate per unit comes down, so that stock is never carried above actual cost. Variable overheads are absorbed on actual use of the production facilities.

Joint products, by-products and other costs

Where one process yields joint products and the conversion cost of each cannot be identified, paragraph 10 asks for a rational and consistent split, for example on relative sales value. Immaterial by-products, scrap and waste are often measured at net realisable value and deducted from the cost of the main product. Paragraphs 11 and 12 allow other costs only if they bring the goods to their present location and condition, such as design costs for a specific customer. Interest and other borrowing costs usually do not meet that test and stay out. The narrow exception for stock that takes a substantial period to get ready for sale is dealt with in capitalising borrowing costs on qualifying assets under AS 16.

Costs that must be kept out of inventory

Paragraph 13 lists four costs that are expensed in the year they arise, however closely they seem connected with the stock:

Excluded cost (para 13)Typical example in an Indian businessException to watch
Abnormal wastage of materials, labour or other production costsMaterial spoiled in a machine breakdown or floodNormal process loss stays in cost
Storage costsGodown rent for finished goods awaiting dispatchStorage necessary between two production stages, such as maturing
Administrative overheadsHead office accounts and HR salariesOnly overheads that help bring the stock to its location and condition
Selling and distribution costsOutward freight, sales commission, advertisementNone; these never enter cost

Choosing a cost formula: specific identification, FIFO or weighted average

Paragraph 14 requires specific identification for items that are not ordinarily interchangeable and for goods produced and kept aside for specific projects, such as a custom-built machine or individually numbered jewellery. Paragraph 15 explains why it is not allowed for large volumes of interchangeable items: picking which units to treat as sold would let management adjust profit.

For everything else, paragraph 16 requires either first-in, first-out (FIFO) or weighted average cost, whichever gives the fairest approximation of the cost incurred in bringing the items to their present location and condition. AS 2 offers no LIFO option. Under paragraph 17, the weighted average can be worked out periodically or each time a fresh lot is received.

Illustration of the difference, for a trader in FY 2025-26: opening stock 100 units at ₹200, purchases of 300 units at ₹220 and then 200 units at ₹250, sales of 400 units, leaving 200 units at 31 March 2026.

  • FIFO: the 200 units left are the latest lot, so closing stock is 200 × ₹250 = ₹50,000.
  • Periodic weighted average: total cost ₹1,36,000 for 600 units gives ₹226.67 a unit, so closing stock is about ₹45,333.

The ₹4,667 gap flows straight into profit. Whichever formula you pick, apply it consistently year after year. Moving from one to the other is a change in the method used to prepare the accounts, which is how a change in accounting policy is described in prior period items, estimates and policy changes under AS 5.

Paragraphs 18 and 19 also allow two shortcuts if the results approximate actual cost. Standard costing is acceptable when the standards reflect normal levels of materials, labour, efficiency and capacity and are reviewed regularly. Under the retail method, an appropriate gross margin percentage is deducted from the sales value of stock. The retail method suits retailers with many fast-moving items of similar margin.

Testing net realisable value item by item

Net realisable value (NRV) is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less the estimated costs of completion and the estimated costs needed to make the sale. Paragraph 20 points to the usual triggers: damage, obsolescence, a fall in selling price, or a rise in the cost to complete or sell.

Paragraph 21 says the write-down is normally done item by item. Grouping similar items in the same product line is allowed in limited cases, but writing down on the basis of a whole classification such as "finished goods" or an entire segment is not. A profit on one product cannot absorb a loss on another.

Paragraph 22 asks for the most reliable evidence available when the estimate is made, including events after the balance sheet date to the extent they confirm conditions existing at that date. A distress sale of the same goods in April at a lower price is often that evidence; the reasoning is the same as in adjusting and non-adjusting events after the balance sheet date under AS 4.

Paragraph 23 adds that stock held to fill firm sales contracts is measured against the contract price, and only the quantity beyond the contract is tested against general selling prices.

Raw materials are tested through the finished product

Paragraph 24 stops a common over-provision. Materials and supplies held for production are not written down just because their own market price has fallen, as long as the finished products they go into are expected to sell at or above cost. Only when the finished product will sell below cost are the materials written down, and then replacement cost may be the best available measure of their NRV.

Worked example: a manufacturer's closing stock at 31 March 2026

Illustration only. A company has normal capacity of 10,000 units a year. In FY 2025-26 it produced only 8,000 units because of a two-month power shortage. Production costs for the year were:

  • material ₹300 a unit (purchase price ₹280, inward freight ₹15, handling ₹5; GST fully creditable and therefore excluded);
  • direct labour ₹80 a unit;
  • variable production overheads ₹4,00,000;
  • fixed production overheads ₹12,00,000;
  • material worth ₹60,000 destroyed in a godown leak, treated as abnormal wastage.

Step 1, overhead rates. Fixed overhead is absorbed at ₹12,00,000 ÷ 10,000 = ₹120 a unit, not ₹150 on actual output. Only 8,000 × ₹120 = ₹9,60,000 is absorbed; the balance ₹2,40,000 is expensed. Variable overhead is ₹4,00,000 ÷ 8,000 = ₹50 a unit.

Step 2, cost per unit. ₹300 + ₹80 + ₹50 + ₹120 = ₹550. The ₹60,000 abnormal loss is charged to profit and loss and never enters this figure.

Step 3, NRV test. 1,500 units are in stock, costing 1,500 × ₹550 = ₹8,25,000. They fall into three groups:

GroupUnitsExpected price less cost to sellNRV per unitCarried atAmount
Good stock, open market700₹700 less ₹40₹660Cost ₹550₹3,85,000
Good stock under a firm contract300Contract ₹530 less ₹10₹520NRV ₹520₹1,56,000
Damaged stock500₹520 less ₹30₹490NRV ₹490₹2,45,000
Total1,500Item-by-item comparisonNot applicableLower of the two₹7,86,000

The write-down is ₹8,25,000 less ₹7,86,000 = ₹39,000. Notice that the ₹77,000 margin on the 700 open-market units (₹110 each) does not offset the loss on the other two groups, because paragraph 21 bars that netting.

Step 4, raw materials. The company also holds 2,000 kg of material bought at ₹150 a kg, now replaceable at ₹130. Because the open-market finished goods sell above cost, no write-down is needed on material going into them. If the material were earmarked for products that will sell below cost, it would be written down to ₹130 a kg, a charge of 2,000 × ₹20 = ₹40,000.

Year-end review and disclosure

Paragraph 25 requires NRV to be assessed afresh at each balance sheet date. AS 2 has no separate paragraph on reversing an earlier write-down, but the lower-of-cost-and-NRV test is repeated every year and the carrying amount can never exceed cost. Keep the working that supports each write-down, because auditors test it alongside the count. The audit side is set out in physical inventory count procedures under SA 501, and for companies within CARO the same stock figures feed CARO 2020 clause 3(ii) reporting on inventory and stock statements.

Under paragraph 26, the financial statements must disclose the accounting policy for measuring inventories, including the cost formula used, and the total carrying amount with its classification. Paragraph 27 gives the usual classes: raw materials and components, work in progress, finished goods, stock-in-trade, stores and spares, loose tools and others named by nature. A note that says only "inventories are valued at cost or market price, whichever is lower" falls short on two counts: it names no cost formula, and "market price" is not the NRV measure the standard uses.

Regulatory details may change. Confirm current official guidance before acting.

Latest job openings

See all GST Jobs →

Related Articles

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe to get updates on the latest Job Openings, News and Articles.

Submit

© 2026 CA Samaaj. All rights reserved.

Get it on Google Play