A foreign company has a permanent establishment (PE) in India when it carries on business here through a fixed place, a long-running site or service project, or a dependent agent. Each of these is defined in the PE article of the tax treaty with its home country. The PE question decides whether India can tax the company's business profits at all. Under most Indian treaties, business profits are taxable in India only if there is a PE, and then only the profit attributable to it.
Indian domestic law asks a wider question first: does the non-resident have a business connection in India? Where a treaty applies and is more favourable, the narrower PE test usually controls the outcome. So the working order for any inbound engagement is simple. Check business connection under the Income-tax Act, check PE under the relevant treaty, and apply whichever gives the lower tax.
Business connection comes first, under section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 2025
From tax year 2026-27, section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 deems income arising through any business connection in India to accrue or arise in India (section 9(2)(c)). For earlier years the same idea sits in section 9(1)(i) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Section 9(9) of the 2025 Act fills in the detail.
A business carried out in India includes business activity done through a person acting for the non-resident who:
- has and habitually exercises an authority to conclude contracts for the non-resident, or habitually concludes contracts or plays the principal role leading to their conclusion, where the contracts are in the non-resident's name, transfer or license its property, or are for services it provides;
- has no such authority but habitually maintains a stock of goods in India and regularly delivers from it for the non-resident; or
- habitually secures orders in India mainly or wholly for the non-resident or its group companies.
A broker, general commission agent or other agent of independent status, acting in the ordinary course of business, does not create a business connection. That protection is lost where the agent works mainly or wholly for one non-resident and its related entities; section 9(9)(b)(ii) says such a person is not treated as independent.
Section 9(9) also contains the significant economic presence test (transactions above a prescribed amount, or systematic soliciting of, or interaction with, a prescribed number of users in India). It also lists carve-outs, such as operations confined to buying goods in India for export. Even where a business connection exists, section 9(9)(f) deems only the income reasonably attributable to the Indian operations to arise in India.
Why the treaty PE test usually decides the tax
Under section 159(4) of the 2025 Act, the Act applies only to the extent it is more beneficial to the taxpayer where India has a tax treaty with the other country. Two limits come with that. Section 159(6) keeps Chapter XI of the Act applicable even where it is not beneficial, and section 159(8) requires a non-resident to hold a certificate of residence from its home country before claiming treaty relief.
The residence certificate alone is not enough on the e-filing side. The Form 41 user manual on the e-filing portal explains that a non-resident claiming relief under a tax treaty files Form 41. The form carries the information required by Rule 75, and a copy of the section 159(8) certificate is a prerequisite. The difference between a TRC and the treaty information form trips up many payers, and it is worth settling before any payment goes out.
Most treaties tax business profits only through a PE. Article 7 of the India-USA treaty is a typical example. A US enterprise's business profits can be taxed in India only if it carries on business here through a PE. Even then, India taxes only the profit the PE would have earned as an independent entity. So a business connection without a PE generally leaves those profits outside Indian tax for a treaty resident.
The four ways a PE arises under the India-USA treaty
Treaties differ in thresholds, so always read the PE article (usually Article 5) of the treaty that applies. The India-USA convention is a useful working model because the US Treasury's Technical Explanation of the India-USA tax convention explains each paragraph in plain terms.
| Type of PE | What triggers it | Time test |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed place PE | A fixed place through which the business is wholly or partly carried on, such as a place of management, branch, office, factory, workshop, mine, a warehouse providing storage to others, or a sales outlet | No day count; permanence of the place matters |
| Construction or installation PE | A building site or construction project, or an installation or drilling rig | More than 120 days in a twelve-month period |
| Service PE | Services (other than fees for included services) furnished in India through employees or other personnel | More than 90 days in a twelve-month period; no threshold if the services are for a related enterprise |
| Dependent agent PE | An agent who habitually exercises authority to conclude contracts in the enterprise's name, habitually keeps a stock of goods for delivery, or habitually secures orders wholly or almost wholly for the enterprise | No day count; habitual conduct is the test |
For the service PE, related means associated under Article 9 of that treaty: one enterprise participates in the management, control or capital of the other, or a common person does so for both. A US parent sending staff to perform services for its Indian subsidiary can therefore have a service PE from the first day, which surprises many groups.
What does not create a PE
Paragraph 3 of the PE article excludes places used solely for preparatory or auxiliary activities. Under the India-USA treaty that covers facilities used only for storage, display or occasional delivery of the enterprise's own goods, stock kept only for processing by another enterprise, and a fixed place used only to buy goods or collect information.
Two other points regularly decide disputes:
- Independent agents. A broker or commission agent of independent status acting in the ordinary course of business does not create a PE.
- Subsidiaries. An Indian subsidiary is not a PE of its foreign parent merely because of control. It becomes one only if it meets one of the tests above, for example by habitually concluding contracts for the parent or providing a fixed place at the parent's disposal.
The protocol and notes on the India-USA treaty page of the Income Tax Department add two refinements. For the site, installation and service PEs, no PE is deemed to exist in a year in which the activity lasts less than 30 days. And an agent counts as habitually securing orders wholly or almost wholly for the enterprise only when it frequently accepts orders, does substantially all the sales-related work and is presented as able to bind the enterprise.
Counting days for a service PE: a worked illustration
Illustration only. A US software company with no Indian group entity sends one project team to an unrelated Indian client to configure and test a system. The fees are not fees for included services. The team is in India on three visits during 2026.
| Visit | Dates in India | Days counted |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4 May 2026 to 18 June 2026 | 46 |
| 2 | 3 August 2026 to 28 August 2026 | 26 |
| 3 | 5 October 2026 to 24 October 2026 | 20 |
| Total | Within one twelve-month window | 92 |
At 92 days the team crosses the 90-day threshold, so the company has a service PE in India for this project. India can then tax the profit attributable to that PE.
Now suppose the third visit ends on 22 October 2026. Visit 3 becomes 18 days and the total becomes exactly 90. The treaty asks for more than 90 days, so 90 days does not create a service PE. A two-day change in travel plans moves the whole contract in or out of Indian tax, which is why day logs per engagement matter.
Three cautions apply to this kind of count. The treaty speaks of a twelve-month period, not the Indian tax year, so test the busiest rolling window. If the same team also worked from a client office placed at its disposal, check the fixed place test separately. And if the client were an Indian subsidiary of the same group, the 90-day threshold would not apply at all.
What follows once a PE exists
Only the profit attributable to the PE is taxable in India, worked out as if the PE were a separate and independent enterprise. Royalties and fees for included services have their own treaty article and can be taxed in India at source whether or not there is a PE, so the PE finding does not settle the tax on every payment.
For the Indian payer, the PE finding changes withholding. A payment that is business profit of a treaty resident without a PE may need no Indian tax deduction. The same payment to a foreign company with a PE carries tax on the attributable profit, and the payer's remittance reporting must reflect that. The Form 145 and Form 146 remittance process is where that view gets recorded before money leaves India.
For the foreign enterprise, income taxable in India means an Indian return, a PAN and documents supporting how profit was split between the PE and head office. Contracts, travel records, the role of Indian sales staff and who signs customer agreements are the documents an assessing officer asks for first.
Before relying on any treaty threshold, open the PE article of the specific treaty and its protocol, because the day counts, the service PE clause and the agency wording vary from treaty to treaty.
