Skip to main content

GST on Corporate Guarantee: Delhi High Court Reads Down 1% Rule 28(2), Taxes Full Tenure

10 min read
GST on Corporate Guarantee

GST on corporate guarantees given to group companies stays, but the 1% deemed value can no longer be treated as a floor. In a 119-page judgment pronounced on 17 November 2026 in Sterlite Power Transmission Limited v. Union of India, W.P.(C) 2966/2024 and 15 connected petitions, a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court (Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar) held that a guarantee furnished to a bank or financial institution for a related company's borrowings is a supply of services even when no fee is charged, and then read down Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, 2017 so that a supplier can prove a lower open market value.

The bench also rejected the department's year-by-year approach. A guarantee is supplied once, on execution, and tax is computed for its full tenure; each renewal, extension of tenure or increase in amount is a fresh supply valued only for the added period or amount. Guarantees executed before 1 July 2017 and never renewed are outside GST altogether, and the 1% figure cannot be pushed back to guarantees executed between 1 July 2017 and 25 October 2023.

The petitioners were a cross-section of Indian groups with large intra-group guarantee books: Renew, Jindal Stainless Hisar, Azure Power, GAIL (India), Essar Power, Essar Shipping, Avaada Energy, Hero Future Energies, Logix Realtors and others. Show cause notices, orders and demands against them have been set aside to the extent they conflict with the findings, and proper officers must now redetermine liability after a fresh hearing.

Rule 28(2) and the two circulars that were challenged

Rule 28(2) was inserted by Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax dated 26 October 2023 on the recommendation of the 52nd GST Council meeting. As amended by Notification No. 12/2024-Central Tax dated 10 July 2024 with effect from 26 October 2023, it values a corporate guarantee given to a related person located in India, in favour of a banking company or financial institution, at 1% of the guaranteed amount per annum or the actual consideration, whichever is higher. A proviso makes the invoice value the deemed value where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit. The department explained before the court that the 1% figure was drawn from the income-tax safe harbour in Rule 10TD.

CBIC followed with Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST dated 27 October 2023 and Circular No. 225/19/2024-GST dated 11 July 2024. The second circular told officers that the value is 1% per year of the amount guaranteed, that each renewal is taxed afresh and that guarantees issued before 26 October 2023 were already taxable under the earlier valuation rule. The petitioners challenged all of this, along with the basic proposition that a free intra-group guarantee is a supply at all.

Why a free guarantee to a subsidiary is still a taxable supply

The petitioners argued that a holding company guaranteeing its subsidiary's loan acts as a shareholder protecting its investment, that there is no consideration, that the lender and not the subsidiary is the real beneficiary, and that a guarantee is either an actionable claim under Schedule III or a security. The court rejected each argument.

It held that the service is the guarantor's assumption of the related person's default risk, which extends the guarantor's creditworthiness to that person, and that this has value from the moment of execution whether or not the guarantee is ever invoked. Entry 2 of Schedule I dispenses with consideration for related-party supplies made in the course of business; it does not dispense with the need for a supply, and here there is one. The absence of a fee matters only for valuation. The recipient is the related person on whose behalf the guarantee is given, under section 2(93)(c), reasoned from who receives the service rather than from privity of contract. The bench departed from the service-tax era decisions in Edelweiss and D.P. Jain on the ground that they arose under a different charging scheme.

The exclusion arguments failed as well. The subsidiary receives credit support, not a claim, so Entry 6 of Schedule III does not apply, and a guarantee is not a security under section 2(102). Different treatment of personal guarantees given by directors was upheld because it rests on a general restriction on paying directors for such guarantees.

How the 1% deemed value was read down

The court found Rule 28(2) within the rule-making power under sections 15 and 164, and accepted that 1% is a rational starting point. What it struck at was the words that made 1% a fixed minimum. A deemed value that can never be displaced, even where the guarantor shows the real market price of the guarantee is lower, was held arbitrary under Article 14. The rule now operates as a rebuttable presumption: the deemed value yields to a lower open market value proved on cogent, verifiable material.

The burden of proving that lower value is on the supplier, and the proper officer can test the material. The judgment points to fair-value measurements, accepted transfer-pricing benchmarks and credit-rating-based pricing as the kind of evidence that can work. A nominal or nil fee agreed within the group is not, by itself, evidence of market value.

The proviso that makes invoice value the deemed value where the recipient can take full input tax credit was upheld because the transaction is revenue-neutral in that case. The bench added a limit that will matter in adjudication: eligibility for full credit is a question of fact and cannot be presumed merely because the parties are related.

Which guarantees are taxable, and under which rule

The judgment draws three time bands, keyed to the date on which a guarantee was executed, renewed, extended or enhanced.

Guarantee executed (or last renewed, extended or enhanced)Taxable?How it is valued
Before 1 July 2017, never renewed, extended or enhancedNoNot applicable; continuing into the GST period does not create a supply
1 July 2017 to 25 October 2023YesUnder the valuation rules then in force, including the invoice-value proviso (now in Rule 28(1)) where full credit applies; Rule 28(2) cannot be used, and Rule 31 cannot import 1% as a uniform measure
On or after 26 October 2023YesRule 28(2) as read down: 1% per annum of the amount guaranteed, or a lower open market value the supplier proves

For the middle band, the value must rest on material specific to the guarantee. An officer cannot reach for Rule 31, the residual method, and simply apply 1% a year, because that would give Rule 28(2) retrospective effect by another route. The retrospective operation of Notification No. 12/2024 from 26 October 2023 was upheld: it added the words "located in India", which the court called beneficial, and "per annum", which it treated as clarificatory, and its reach back was under nine months.

Guarantees given for recipients outside India before 26 October 2023 were not decided; that question goes to the adjudicating authority. Pre-2017 deeds need a deed-by-deed check, since any renewal, extension or enhancement after 1 July 2017 brings that event into GST.

Single supply on execution, tax for the full tenure

The department's alternative case was that a fresh time of supply arises every year when the subsidiary records the guarantee in its books under Ind AS 24, so that 1% could be charged on the subsisting amount annually. The court rejected this. A guarantee is not a continuous supply of services under section 2(33), because there are no periodic payment obligations, and a valuation fiction in Rule 28(2) cannot create one. Time of supply falls under section 13(2)(a) or (b), not section 13(2)(c).

Tax is therefore computed on execution for the whole tenure. The bench recognised that this front-loads the burden and said the authorities may regulate collection in annual instalments, for example by notification under section 148. Each renewal, extension of tenure or enhancement of amount is a fresh supply, valued on the renewed period or on the increase, so the same risk is not taxed twice. If a guarantee is released early, the supplier may reduce the tax for the unexpired period by issuing a credit note under section 34, within that section's conditions and time limits. That relief does not arise merely because the guaranteed loan was never disbursed, since the guarantor's exposure continues.

Illustration (figures assumed): a parent executes a five-year guarantee of ₹100 crore for its subsidiary's term loan on 1 December 2023, charging no fee, and the subsidiary is not eligible for full credit. On the department's year-wise reading, the value would be ₹1 crore every year with GST at 18% of ₹18 lakh a year. Under the judgment, the supply is complete on 1 December 2023 and the value covers the whole tenure: 1% × 5 years × ₹100 crore = ₹5 crore, with GST of ₹90 lakh, though collection may be spread if the government provides for instalments. If the parent proves, on a credit-rating-based pricing study, that the market rate for such a guarantee is 0.40% a year, the value falls to ₹2 crore and the GST to ₹36 lakh. If the bank releases the guarantee after two years, a credit note can reduce the tax attributable to the remaining three years.

What the ruling means for the CBIC circulars and pending notices

Circulars 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST were held not ultra vires section 168, but they bind only officers and must now be read consistently with the judgment. They cannot stop a supplier from proving a lower open market value, and they cannot treat the mere continued existence of a pre-26 October 2023 guarantee as a fresh supply. The circular's statement that value is 1% "per year", read as an annual levy, sits uneasily with the court's single-supply holding, and officers in Delhi will have to apply the judgment's version.

The ruling arrives after the Gujarat High Court's decision in Torrent Power Ltd. v. Union of India, reported in August 2026, which also upheld taxability, struck down the levy on related-party guarantees furnished before 26 October 2023 and removed the "whichever is higher" mechanism from Rule 28(2). The Delhi bench reaches a similar result on the 1% floor but differs in its route on some points, including by declining to rely on section 145 of the Contract Act. With two High Courts now reading the valuation rule down, a Supreme Court appeal by the revenue is the obvious next step to watch.

Several questions were left expressly open for the adjudicating authorities: whether extended limitation under section 74 can be invoked in these cases, whether a pledge of shares is taxable alongside or instead of a guarantee, actual eligibility for full input tax credit, the open market value in each case, and the precise dates of execution, renewal, extension or enhancement for each deed. For groups now facing redetermination, the deed register and pricing evidence will decide the outcome: map every guarantee to one of the three time bands, identify renewals and enhancements, and assemble benchmark material before the fresh hearing.

The additional issues raised in W.P.(C) 15738/2024 (Azure Power) and W.P.(C) 12955/2025 (JITF Urban Infrastructure), beyond the corporate guarantee questions, are listed before the roster bench on 9 December 2026, subject to the orders of the Chief Justice.

Official source: View the official source document

Latest job openings

See all GST Jobs →

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe to get updates on the latest Job Openings, News and Articles.

Submit

© 2026 CA Samaaj. All rights reserved.

Get it on Google Play