Mutual Fund Units Not Shares Under India-Mauritius DTAA: Delhi HC Clears ₹593 Crore Gains
Capital gains on mutual fund units under the India-Mauritius DTAA cannot be taxed in India as gains from shares, the Delhi High Court held on 18 November 2026. A Division Bench of Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar dismissed the Revenue's appeal in ITA 720/2025, Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-1, New Delhi v. Emerging India Focus Funds, and confirmed that ₹593.48 crore of gains a Mauritius fund made by selling units of Indian equity-oriented mutual funds in Assessment Year 2022-23 fall outside Article 13(3A) of the treaty.
The Court's central finding is short: a unit holder is not a shareholder of the companies in which the mutual fund invests. Article 13(3A) lets India tax gains from the alienation of shares of an Indian company acquired on or after 1 April 2017. Units are a different security, so the gains go to Article 13(4), the residuary clause, under which they are taxable only in the country where the seller is resident. For this assessee, that is Mauritius.
Emerging India Focus Funds: how ₹593.48 crore became a dispute
The assessee is a company resident in Mauritius, registered with SEBI as a Foreign Institutional Investor. It pools money from investors abroad and, according to the facts recorded in the judgment, invests only in SEBI-registered mutual funds. Its return for Assessment Year 2022-23, filed on 13 October 2022, declared total income of ₹5,460 and claimed capital gains of ₹5,93,48,24,274 from the sale of units of equity-oriented mutual funds as exempt under Article 13 of the treaty.
The case was picked for scrutiny under CASS and a notice under Section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 was issued on 31 May 2023. The Assessing Officer's draft order of 28 March 2024 looked through the units to the portfolio behind them. Since an equity-oriented fund must keep more than 65% of its investible funds in domestic equity shares, the officer treated 65% of the gains, ₹385,76,35,779, as gains from shares taxable under Article 13(3A). The Dispute Resolution Panel, in its order of 3 December 2024, went further: if units are equivalent to equity shares, the whole ₹593.48 crore is taxable, not a 65% slice.
The assessee won before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal on 25 June 2025 in ITA No. 1963/Del/2025. The Tribunal held that Article 13(3A) applies only to alienation of shares and relied on the definition of share in Section 2(84) of the Companies Act, 2013, the definitions of securities and pooled investment vehicle in the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, and the fact that Indian mutual funds are constituted as trusts. The Revenue then appealed to the High Court under Section 260A.
The positions taken at each stage show how far apart the two sides were:
| Stage | Date | Amount treated as taxable in India | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assessing Officer (draft order) | 28 March 2024 | ₹385.76 crore (65% of gains) | Look-through to the equity share portion of the funds |
| Dispute Resolution Panel | 3 December 2024 | ₹593.48 crore (entire gains) | Units of equity-oriented funds equivalent to equity shares |
| ITAT Delhi | 25 June 2025 | Nil | Article 13(3A) covers only shares; units are a distinct security |
| Delhi High Court | 18 November 2026 | Nil | Unit holder is not a shareholder; gains fall under Article 13(4) |
Why the Delhi High Court said mutual fund units are not shares
The Revenue argued that an equity-oriented fund holds mainly equity shares, so selling its units is in substance selling shares, and asked the Court to read Article 13(3A) purposively. The assessee, represented by Senior Advocate Ajay Vohra, relied on the statutory definitions and argued that the gains belonged under Article 13(4).
The Bench began with the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996. Regulation 2(q) defines a mutual fund as a fund established as a trust that raises money through the sale of units, and Regulation 2(z) defines a unit as the interest of unit holders in a scheme, each unit representing one undivided share in the assets of the scheme. From this the Court concluded that "the holder of a mutual fund is not an owner of equity share in a company", and that "the unit holder does not have any rights and liabilities of the shareholder."
It then pointed to the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, whose definition of securities in Section 2(h) lists shares and units of mutual fund schemes as separate items, and to Section 10(38) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which dealt with long-term gains on equity shares and on units of equity-oriented funds as two distinct categories. Indian law itself, the Court reasoned, keeps the two apart.
The Court also leaned on the Supreme Court's decision in Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CIT, (2002) 9 SCC 1, where units of UTI were held not to be shares. Quoting that ruling, the Bench noted that if the legislature had meant units to be treated as deemed shares, "then it would have stated so."
On interpretation, the Bench held that treaty provisions "have to be read very strictly" and rejected the call for a purposive reading. Article 13(3A) covers only gains from alienation of shares; Article 13(4) covers every other property. The Tribunal had rested part of its reasoning on the idea that one could look at the underlying sale of shares; the High Court disagreed with that approach as well, observing that every DTAA is worded differently and that the assessee held units, not shares of any company. The question of law was answered in favour of the assessee and the appeal was dismissed.
What the ruling changes for FPIs, funds and tax advisers
The decisive test is the nature of the asset sold, not the composition of the fund's portfolio. The 65% domestic equity threshold that makes a scheme equity-oriented has no bearing on treaty classification under this judgment. That knocks out both the proportionate approach of the Assessing Officer and the all-or-nothing approach of the Panel.
For Mauritius-resident investors holding units of Indian schemes, the judgment is a jurisdictional High Court ruling for assessments framed by the International Taxation charges in Delhi, which brought this appeal. Assessments and appeals for other years raising the same Article 13(3A) look-through argument can now be met with this decision, and draft orders taxing a percentage of unit gains as share gains should be challenged on this footing before the Dispute Resolution Panel.
The ruling is narrower for investors from other countries. The Court's reasoning turned on the specific text of Article 13(3A) and 13(4) of the India-Mauritius treaty, and the Bench itself said each DTAA differs. An investor resident elsewhere has to read the capital gains article of its own treaty: whether it carves out shares alone, or uses wider language that could catch units or interests in entities deriving value from shares, decides whether the same argument works.
Two limits inside Article 13(3A) itself also matter. It applies only to shares acquired on or after 1 April 2017, so gains on older shareholdings were already outside it. And because the treaty text decides the outcome, the reasoning is not tied to the Income-tax Act, 1961 under which this appeal was filed; the same Article 13 wording continues to govern the classification question.
Supreme Court appeal is the next date to watch
With ₹593.48 crore of gains at stake on a contested treaty reading, the Revenue may seek special leave to appeal before the Supreme Court. Unless the Supreme Court takes up the issue and holds otherwise, the Delhi High Court's answer stands: gains from selling units of Indian equity-oriented mutual funds by a Mauritius resident are taxable only in Mauritius under Article 13(4), and the 65% equity look-through used in this assessment has no footing in the treaty.
Official source: View the official source document
