Skip to main content

Videocon Resolution Plan: Supreme Court Upholds NCLAT Remand, Sets 5 Guardrails

9 min read
Videocon Resolution Plan

The Supreme Court on 16 November 2026 dismissed Twinstar Technologies Limited's appeals against the NCLAT order that had set aside approval of the ₹2,962.02 crore Videocon resolution plan, so the plan for Videocon Industries Limited and twelve other group companies goes back to the committee of creditors (CoC). The judgment in Twinstar Technologies Limited v. Bank of Maharashtra & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 894 of 2022 with connected appeals, reported as 2026 INSC 1214, was delivered by a Bench of Justice P.S. Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe, with Justice Aradhe writing for the Court.

Two findings will travel well beyond Videocon. The Court confirmed that the NCLAT can remit an approved resolution plan to the CoC instead of only approving or rejecting it, and it laid down five guardrails for using that power. It also held that a plan which pays dissenting financial creditors through debentures redeemable over six years does not make the "payment" that Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 requires, and that the adjudicating authority cannot repair that defect by rewriting the payment terms itself.

How the Videocon plan was structured and who opposed it

Section 7 applications against thirteen Videocon group companies were admitted in 2018, and the NCLT consolidated the insolvency processes on 8 August 2019. Eleven resolution plans came in. At the CoC meeting of 2 September 2020, fair value stood at ₹4,069.95 crore and liquidation value at ₹2,568.13 crore. Twinstar's amended plan of 7 November 2020 offered a total outlay of ₹2,962.02 crore, made up as follows.

ComponentAmountTiming and terms
Upfront payment to financial creditors₹200 croreOn implementation
Workmen and employees₹52 croreUpfront
Operational creditors₹10 croreUpfront
Non-convertible debentures₹2,700 crore face value6.65% coupon; ₹200 crore due 25 months after closing, then four instalments of ₹625 crore each in years three to six
Equity8% of Videocon IndustriesAllotted to financial creditors

On 11 December 2020 the CoC approved the plan with 95.09% of the voting share. Four financial creditors holding about 3.077% dissented: Bank of Maharashtra (1.97%), IFCI (1.03%), SIDBI (0.053%) and ABG Shipyard (0.024%). Their estimated entitlement was ₹105.23 crore in Form H and ₹114.21 crore in the SBI Caps distribution sheet. The promoter's Section 12A withdrawal proposal was rejected by 98.14%.

The NCLT approved the plan on 8 June 2021, recording a haircut of 95.85% on admitted claims of ₹64,838.63 crore and a recovery of 0.72% for operational creditors. To deal with the dissenters' objection, it directed that they be paid their liquidation value in cash, upfront. The NCLAT stayed that approval on 19 July 2021. In September 2021 the CoC, through SBI and with about 94.98% of the voting share, told the NCLAT it wanted the plan sent back for reconsideration, and on 5 January 2022 the NCLAT set aside the approval and remitted the matter. A week later the CoC resolved, by 97%, to invite fresh expressions of interest, but the Supreme Court issued notice on 14 February 2022 and asked the CoC not to proceed.

Debentures are not "payment" to dissenting financial creditors

Section 30(2)(b) requires a plan to provide for payment to dissenting financial creditors of not less than what they would get in liquidation, and Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations requires that payment to be made in priority to assenting financial creditors. Following its 2021 ruling in Jaypee Kensington, reported at (2022) 1 SCC 401, the Court read "payment" as money only (paras 27.2 and 27.3). Debentures redeemable over six years did not qualify, and the plan gave the dissenters no priority either.

Twinstar pointed to clause 3.5.7 of its plan, a general promise to comply with Section 30(2)(b). The Court rejected that: a general stipulation of compliance with the law, it said, cannot substitute for a specific provision. That line matters to anyone drafting a plan. A blanket compliance clause will not save a payment waterfall that, read on its own terms, leaves dissenters holding paper.

The NCLT's cash-first direction did not cure the defect either. Changing who is paid, how and when alters the commercial structure of the plan, and under Section 30(4) only the CoC can do that. Because the defect went to a ground of appeal under Section 61(3), the NCLAT was right to interfere (para 27.6).

NCLAT's power to send an approved plan back to the CoC

Twinstar argued that the NCLAT, once it found a defect, could only uphold or set aside the plan. The Court disagreed. It held that the appellate power carries every incidental and ancillary power needed to make it effective, read with Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016, which preserves the tribunal's inherent powers (para 25). Rejecting a defective plan outright could push the companies into liquidation, which the Code treats as the last resort, while modifying the plan would trespass on the CoC's commercial domain. Remand sits between the two.

The Court also found support in the 2026 amendment to the Code, which added a proviso to Section 31(2) allowing the adjudicating authority to give the CoC notice to rectify defects before rejecting a plan (para 26.3). In its reading, that proviso confirms a legislative preference for sending defective plans back rather than throwing them out.

Twinstar's fallback request, that any reconsideration be confined to its own plan, failed as well. The Court said it is not for the adjudicating authority, the NCLAT or the Supreme Court to dictate whether the CoC should consider only a modified version of the existing plan or invite fresh plans (para 26.2). That choice belongs to the CoC's commercial wisdom.

The five guardrails for remanding a resolution plan

Because remand also carries costs, including longer litigation, uncertainty for bidders and erosion of asset value, the Court set out conditions in para 70 that every future remand order must meet:

  1. Remand must advance the Code's objectives: keeping the corporate debtor a going concern, fair recovery for every class of creditor and maximising value during the insolvency process. The bare existence of the power does not justify its use.
  2. It must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance, whether with Section 30(2) or with any other law in force, the latter being a ground of appeal under Section 61(3)(i).
  3. It is to be used sparingly and with circumspection, without departing from any express procedure under the Code or crossing the limits the Court has drawn around inherent and implied powers.
  4. It also corrects errors: where the adjudicating authority finds a curable defect and modifies the plan itself instead of remitting it, the NCLAT may remand to restore the division of roles between the adjudicating authority and the CoC.
  5. Every remand order must carry a strict direction to follow the timelines in the Code and the regulations, so that the remedy does not produce the delay the Code is meant to prevent.

CoC is not functus officio once it approves a plan

Twinstar also argued that the CoC, having voted on the plan in December 2020, had no power to revisit it. The Court held that the CoC is a body of creditors, not an adjudicating forum, and that it continues to exist throughout the process. Relying on Kalyani Transco, it said an approved plan does not attain finality until appeals under Sections 61 and 62 are decided (para 29). The binding character of a CoC-approved plan presupposes a plan that complies with the Code. The rulings in Ebix and Amtek Auto, which concerned attempts by resolution applicants to withdraw, did not help Twinstar, and the Court distinguished its October 2026 decision in Kamal Pasha, where a CoC had tried to walk away from a compliant plan for opportunistic reasons.

On one point the Court sided with Twinstar. The NCLAT had held that Competition Commission of India approval under the proviso to Section 31(4) was not shown. Twinstar produced a CCI communication dated 8 December 2020, three days before voting closed on 11 December 2020, and the Court held that the requirement had been met (para 28). That finding did not change the outcome, because the Section 30(2)(b) defect alone justified the remand.

Foreign oil and gas assets stay outside Videocon Industries' estate

A second set of appeals concerned Videocon's participating interests in four Brazilian concessions, held through IBV, and the Nunukan block in Indonesia, held through VINI. The promoter and others wanted those assets pulled into Videocon Industries' insolvency estate. The Court refused, holding that a holding company and its subsidiaries are separate legal persons and that Explanation (b) to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d) exclude a subsidiary's assets from the corporate debtor's estate. The promoter, having earlier acquiesced in the consolidated process and sought to keep these assets out, was estopped from arguing the opposite now.

Those assets had been dealt with in the separate insolvency of Videocon Oil Ventures Limited, where Bharat PetroResources exercised its right of first refusal on 26 May 2023, the NCLT approved the transaction on 26 June 2024 and the deal closed on 2 July 2026. The Court held that the promoter had no standing to challenge it, and it repeated that the size of the haircut and the handling of a Section 12A proposal fall within the CoC's commercial wisdom and are not open to judicial review (para 56).

What the ruling means for pending plans and dissenting lenders

For resolution professionals and bidders, the practical rule is now plain: a plan that pays dissenting financial creditors anything other than money, or that does not pay them ahead of assenting creditors, is open to challenge under Section 61(3), and the tribunal will not patch it with a cash direction. Plans under negotiation that rely on debentures, deferred instalments or equity for the dissenting class need a separate cash entitlement for them, at least equal to liquidation value. Dissenting lenders, for their part, now have a clear Supreme Court statement that their entitlement cannot be paid in paper.

The appeals were dismissed without costs (para 71). GAIL's claim is to be handled by the resolution professional under the Code and the CIRP Regulations, and the NCLAT is to decide GAIL's Company Appeal (AT)(Ins.) No. 908 of 2025 in light of this judgment. Wider reporting of the ruling, including the counsel who appeared, is in Bar and Bench's report on the five remand safeguards. The next step sits with the Videocon CoC, which must now decide, within the Code's timelines, whether to look at a modified Twinstar plan or go back to the market for fresh bids on assets that have been in insolvency since 2018.

Official source: View the official source document

Latest job openings

See all CA Jobs →

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe to get updates on the latest Job Openings, News and Articles.

Submit

© 2026 CA Samaaj. All rights reserved.

Get it on Google Play