Notional Rent on Vacant Property: Delhi HC Deletes ₹3.28 Crore Addition Against DLF
Notional rent on vacant property cannot be taxed where the unit was let out in earlier years and the owner genuinely tried to find a tenant during the year, the Delhi High Court has held. In ITA 126/2019, Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-3 v. DLF Ltd., decided on 18 November 2026, a Division Bench of Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar dismissed the Revenue's appeal and left intact the deletion of a ₹3,28,52,595 addition made on account of notional rent, or annual letting value (ALV), on four vacant commercial units for Assessment Year 2007-08.
The ruling turns on the vacancy allowance in Section 23(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and on one factual line: a unit that has been let before can claim it; a unit that was never let cannot. That line matters to every owner holding commercial space that falls empty between tenancies, and to developers carrying built-up stock.
How the ₹3.28 crore notional rent addition arose
DLF Ltd., a real estate developer, filed its return and a revised return for AY 2007-08. The case was picked for scrutiny, a special audit was directed under Section 142(2A), and the Assessing Officer passed an assessment under Section 143(3) on 7 October 2010 computing total income at ₹750,38,90,009 against returned income of ₹568,54,69,980. The additions came to ₹181,84,20,029.
One of those additions treated vacant property as yielding notional rent. Across three commercial properties, DLF owned 23 units in the year. Nineteen were let. Four stood vacant: LG-23 at City Centre, Gurgaon, and FF (F-034), G-05 and 307-A at Centre Point, Faridabad. The Assessing Officer, drawing on the special auditor's findings for AY 2005-06 and 2006-07, estimated an ALV on these units and taxed it.
The CIT(A), by order dated 29 May 2012, deleted the addition. It accepted that DLF intended to let the units but found no suitable tenant, so the ALV was nil and no notional rent could be estimated. The ITAT, by order dated 1 November 2017 in ITA No. 3846/Del/2012, upheld that view, holding the issue covered by its own earlier order deleting the same addition for AY 2006-07; the Departmental Representative accepted that the issue was covered.
What the Revenue argued before the High Court
The High Court framed five substantial questions of law on 23 September 2026. Both sides agreed that the first four, on proportionate interest, capitalisation of interest, percentage-of-completion revenue and reclassification of income, were already covered by the court's judgments in ITA 926/2016 and ITA 928/2016. Only the fifth survived: whether the ITAT was right to delete the ₹3,28,52,595 addition on account of notional rent on vacant property.
The Revenue's case was that vacant or unsold units in built-up complexes are chargeable under Sections 22 and 23. It relied on Ansal Housing & Constructions Ltd. v. ACIT, (2018) 89 taxmann.com 238 (Delhi), where the Delhi High Court had refused the vacancy benefit. DLF answered that the four units had been let in earlier years, stayed vacant in AY 2007-08 despite its efforts, and so carried a nil ALV under Section 23(1)(c). In compliance with an order dated 13 August 2026, it filed an affidavit with documents showing that it could not find tenants for those units during the year.
Why Section 23(1)(c) applied: the Vivek Jain test
After reproducing Section 23, the court turned to the Andhra Pradesh High Court's decision in Vivek Jain v. CIT, (2011) 337 ITR 74, and stated plainly that it agreed with it. Under that reading, clause (c) needs three things together: the property is let; it was vacant for the whole or part of the year; and because of the vacancy, the rent actually received is lower than the sum it might reasonably be expected to fetch. The clause does not reach property that was never let, and "let" cannot be read as "intended to be let".
Applied to DLF, the test was met. The court recorded that the provision gives a vacancy allowance when it can be shown that the property was let out earlier, and that DLF could not find a suitable tenant for the four units in the relevant year despite genuine efforts. The ALV of those units was therefore nil.
Ansal Housing was distinguished on the same fact. There, the properties had never been let in earlier years, so the clause (c) condition that the property "is let" failed at the threshold. Here, it was satisfied.
The bench added a second reason for not interfering. Citing M. Janardhana Rao v. CIT, (2005) 2 SCC 324, it reiterated that the ITAT is the final authority on facts, and a High Court under Section 260A steps in only on a substantial question of law or a perverse finding. Whether DLF tried to let the units was a finding of fact, concurrently reached by the CIT(A) and the ITAT. The Revenue's case raised no substantial question of law, and the appeal was dismissed.
Vacancy allowance or notional rent: three situations compared
The judgment effectively sorts property into three positions for computing annual value under Section 23:
| Position during the year | Clause (c) available? | Annual value taken |
|---|---|---|
| Let out, occupied for the full year | Not needed | Higher of expected rent and actual rent |
| Let earlier, vacant for whole or part of the year, genuine efforts to re-let | Yes, following DLF and Vivek Jain | Actual rent received or receivable, which can be nil for a full-year vacancy |
| Never let, kept vacant | No, following Ansal Housing | Expected rent, that is, notional rent |
An illustration with assumed figures shows how far apart the outcomes are. Take a shop with a reasonable expected rent of ₹12,00,000 a year. If it was let in the past, fell vacant in April and stayed empty through March despite broker listings and advertisements, the actual rent is nil, the shortfall is caused by vacancy, and the annual value is nil. If it was let for four months at ₹1,00,000 a month and then fell vacant, the actual rent of ₹4,00,000 is below ₹12,00,000 because of the vacancy, so the annual value is ₹4,00,000. If the same shop had never been let at all, the annual value would be the full ₹12,00,000 of notional rent, and the 30% standard deduction would still leave ₹8,40,000 chargeable.
Evidence that carried the claim
The outcome rested on documents. DLF's affidavit showed that each of the four units had a letting history and that the company had tried and failed to find tenants in the year. For anyone claiming a nil or reduced ALV on a previously let property, the record worth keeping is the earlier lease deed or rent receipts, plus contemporaneous proof of efforts to re-let during the year, such as broker mandates, listings and correspondence with prospective tenants. A bare assertion of intention to let did not decide this case; the factual finding of genuine effort, accepted at two appellate levels, did.
Position under Section 21(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025
From Tax Year 2026-27, annual value is computed under Section 21 of the Income-tax Act, 2025. Its sub-section (2) uses the same structure: where the property or any part of it is let and was vacant for the whole or part of the tax year, and owing to that vacancy the rent received or receivable is less than the expected rent under sub-section (1)(a), the annual value is the amount actually received or receivable. Because the "is let" condition carries over in the same words, the distinction drawn in DLF and Ansal Housing between previously let and never-let property should continue to govern disputes under the new law. Returns for Assessment Year 2026-27 and pending assessments for earlier years remain under Section 23 of the 1961 Act.
The judgment is also reported by LiveLaw Biz, which carried the bench's reasoning on Vivek Jain. For the Revenue, the practical consequence is that vacancy alone no longer supports a notional rent addition on a unit with a letting history; the dispute shifts to whether the unit was ever let and whether the efforts to re-let it were real.
Official source: View the official source document
